New to site?


Login

Lost password? (X)

Already have an account?


Signup

(X)

CDL-GCNS Young CSR Leader Award Judging Criteria

The preliminary and final proposals are assessed based on the following criteria and score weightage:

CRITERIAWEIGHTAGE
Successful Alignment of Business and Overall Sustainability Strategy25%
Innovative Thinking and Creativity25%
Involvement of Stakeholders20%
Feasibility, Effectiveness and Financial Management (where applicable)20%
Overall Quality of Proposal10%
Total100%

Scores will be awarded accordingly to the following assessment areas for each criterion:

CRITERIAWEIGHTAGE
Successful Alignment of Business and Overall Sustainability Strategy25%
Clear understanding of the company’s core business and target market5%
Sound analysis of company’s intrinsic social responsibility and main focus of Sustainability strategy10%
Strong relevance between the core business and proposed strategy5%
Sustainability of the proposed strategy5%
Innovative Thinking and Creativity25%
Sound gap analysis on existing programmes5%
Clear evidence of creative and innovative ideas (e.g. avoid highly repeated activities like recycling, tree planting and beach clean-up)10%
Comprehensive strategies which seek behavioural / perceptual change of stakeholders to ensure their continuity and operationalisation10%
Involvement of Stakeholders20%
Clear identification and prioritisation of various issues and stakeholders e.g environment,
employees, contract staff, partners, suppliers, top-level executives, consumers)
10%
Appropriate initiatives and programmes with clear relevance for targeted stakeholders10%
Feasibility, Effectiveness and Financial Management (where applicable)20%
Practicality of proposed ideas5%
Due consideration of limitations and strategies to overcome them5%
Ability of proposal to be implemented, and achieve its aims5%
Ability of proposal to be implemented, and achieve its aims5%
Consideration of costs and balancing projected expenditure to ensure Sustainability contributes rather than detracts from company’s financial success5%
Overall Quality of Proposal10%
Clear presentation and organisation10%